Skip to content

Free guide · no email needed

How to compare contractor quotes, line by line

Why are my contractor quotes so far apart?

When two quotes for the same job are thousands apart, the gap is usually in what one of them left out. A one-number quote with a paragraph can hide a missing plumber, a cheap paint-on waterproofing, a too-low allowance or no permits at all. Vague words do the same thing: "concrete and decking" or "tile shower" tells you nothing about strength, grade or the system behind the tile. And check that they actually measured your home rather than filling in a template. The fair way to compare is to put the quotes side by side, line by line, and ask each contractor to fill the gaps.

Checklist

  • Demolition, protection and debris removal listed
  • Framing and carpentry listed, including shower walls, bench or niche
  • Licensed plumber and electrician in the base price, not tucked into an option
  • The waterproofing system named (for showers: a sheet membrane system like Schluter KERDI, or say what it is)
  • Tile labor and tile material separate, with waste included
  • Each fixture listed, or an allowance that matches what you'd really pick
  • Every upgrade on its own line
  • Permits and inspections: included, or billed at cost, and who pulls them
  • What's NOT included, in writing
  • How hidden problems get priced and approved
  • Payments tied to stages you can see, with a small final payment
  • A written workmanship warranty, with its length
  • They measured your space themselves

If it helps to have someone look at your project, we’re glad to. No pressure. Request a consultation

    Call or textRequest a consultationConsultation